Are we making you hungry?????
Get some cookies delivered straight to you!
Questions on custom orders email us!!!
(we promise to be quick and get right back to you…bakers never sleep!)
Wall of Fame
Wall of Fame
Becoming a FattyCake or giving the gift of a FattyCake is easy and fun for everyone involved. FattyCakesNY will create a custom cookie for you. Tell us what you love and what your cookie dreams are. You name the cookie and send us a photo with you and your cookie and we will post it on our Wall Of Fame page to the left. We can even send your cookies in a custom cookie box made just for your order. Email email@example.com to get started!
Just a taste…
Just a taste…
Some of our most famous cookies!
The Original Fattycake-A ridiculous concoction – chocolate chips, chocolate sandwich cookies, caramel, potato chips, pretzels and oatmeal. Make sure to specify a Vanilla, Peanut Butter or Chocolate cookie base.
The Movie Theater Cookie-This is an extraordinary cookie. It starts as a chocolate chip cookie, then buttered popcorn and Swedish Fish® are added. FattyCakes stops there, but feel free to request a custom mix!
S’mores Please!-A camping experience without the open fire. Grahams, milk chocolate and marshmallows baked to gooey perfection.
The Betty Jo-Your grandma might make a killer Red Velvet cake, but she’s got nothing on this cookie. Red Velvet cookie with white chocolate or semi-sweet chocolate chips (make sure to specify!), filled with cream cheese fudge. More portable than cake for sure.
FattyCakesNY is tipsy with excitement that Sailor Jerry is our new rum partner!
Here at FattyCakesNY we are always looking for fun things to add or use in our cookies.
If you have a product you’re proud of and want us to try out, let us know.
Send Product ideas and info to
FattyCakesNY would not exist without help from the following folks:
Keith Miller – Hands down best husband & Director of HR
Marina Kasper – VP of Marketing and Motivation, excellent at everything
Randy & Gina Taylor – the best parents in the world!
Mike Taylor – best older brother and creator of FCNY’s logo and typeface (emptymountain.org)
Dan Taylor – awesome little brother and owner of a palate stranger than my own.
Ed & Joan Miller – greatest Mom & Dad-in-law – thanks for the support!
Cathy Kwan- For the delicious photos on fattycakesny.com & Fab.com (ck-oneaday.tumblr.com)
Alicja Peterson – created The Peppermint Hot Chocolate, The Applejack, and co-conspirator in the David Lynch series of cookies – you have a beautiful mind!
Mackenzie Smith – Herbin’ Spoonful mastermind that kept me from quitting a million times
Cara Possemato – like the name FattyCakes? Her idea!
FattyCakesNY was founded in 2009 by Jennifer Taylor-Miller.
The short story is that FattyCakesNY began as a mission to make the strangest, tastiest cookies the world has ever known Gummy bears, Twizzlers, popcorn, bacon, Swedish Fish if it was edible, she’d try it in cookie form. Some things failed miserably, while to the surprise of pretty much every friend, family member or co-worker subjected to taste testing, some things were freaking fantastic! Years later, FattyCakesNy bakes on!